Skip to main content

Wednesday night wargame - Jacobites

Last night two secret wargaming friends fought a fictional battle set in the seven years war. 

A new Jacobite rebellion has begun, and the Duke of Athole, in command of around 15,000 men, sought to smash a Goverment Army of around 5,000 men under the command of Lord Falmouth.

The battle was fought using the computer moderated rules Carnage&GloryII.

Even with the assistance of this rule set we did not finish the battle, and it was paused at a potentially significant point.

The player playing the part of the Duke of Athole immediately recognised that his main problem would be command and control, and bringing his full might to bear on the much smaller army.

Lord Falmouth, in this scenario, is an experienced commander, and as such, began his battle in a strong defensive position. The field in front of him would funnel his foe into a smaller front, slowing and preventing them using their superior numbers.

However Falmouth was outnumbered by at least 3-1 and his main issue would be fatigue in his troops.

Both commanders were faced with an 'interesting' tactical battle.

Just to add to their distress, the command and control of their units would take place using written orders. This would build in delays in changing tactical orders in the heat of battle.

The scene was set.....oh, did I mention that Carnage and Glory builds in commander skill and leadership abilities? - so even when their orders arrive at brigade staff, they may not be carried out as intended........

Lord Athole ordered a General advance on a broad front by four of his five brigades. The fifth held back in reserve. Even by reducing his numbers in the assault by a fifth, it would still be tight fit to attack the Goverment lines.

The general advance of the Jacobites.

Lord Falmouth held his breath, but told people near to him that he was confident he would hold the line. Meanwhile Athole was contemplating the huge number of troops moving toward the enemy, he knew his sheer numbers would be his main problem.

The right wing of the Jacobite behemoth. I took this 'action shot' for you grass roots wargamers....

The Goverment artillery soon found targets to fire at.

Artillery began to fall on the advancing clans men as they closed on the 'thin red line'.

It wasn't long before the first Jacobites closed on the Goverment first line. Even Falmouth held his breath at this point (and it was nothing to do with the pickled gherkins he had been munching).

The disparity in army size can be seen from this angle, as can Duke of Atholes problem with his 'room to manoeuvre'

Soon the battle was joined.

The Duke of Athole watched has his fearsome clansmen charged toward the Goverment battalions, they found themselves under sustained fire, and one Jacobite Regiment after the other failed to charge and break the line, choosing to find cover in the face of the wall of lead. It was at this time their lack of professional training began to show.

Only his musket men successfully engaged the enemy, and two cavalry charges were blunted by canister shot on his left flank.

Despite the urging of senior commanders, the raw troops in the clan regiments failed to make their charges.

Sustained fire by the Goverment troops kept the horde at bay.

Both sides exchanged musket fire

The arrival of more Jacobites added to the general confusion.

You can see the 'log jam' developing in front of Falmouths defences. It was not all one way, the Goverment forces were beginning to tire.

' Why us Sarge?' - 'Cos we are here laddy, nobody else'

The Goverment line held, despite significant pressure from the Jacobite forces.

'Do you have a flag?' - 'No Flag? - no country!'

Then, one of the Goverment battalions, who had been engaged for an hour in heavy fire pulled back, running through the battalions behind. Falmouth had seen the signs earlier, but had hoped they would hold. It was a gamble.

Moral in nearby battalions was affected.

It was at this point the battle was be continued next Wednesday.

Stay tuned.


  1. How do you say Athole. Did he have a lisp.

  2. Wow what great figures, are they 28mm? The computer rules are very good, I have used them in my own campaigns from time to time. I must admit that they are however still not as good as rolling the dice and hoping that your troops pull off that chance victory. Technology is our friend. Great write up Secret Wargamer.

  3. Ooops sorry, came upon this site by accident as I was looking for tartan cloth designs for the great sewing bee competition. Like the site with those toy soldiers though. Do they actually do tartan paint? I do like a man in a skirt :] Keep up the good work. x

  4. Great write up secret wargamer. Can't wait to read the outcome next week. My money's on the good old British troops. Lord Falmouth appears to be a very steady and professional leader.

  5. Great looking game SW. Do you have your own wargames room to be able to leave the game where it is. That's awesome if you do. Keep up the good work.

  6. Great looking game, I do prefer your reports on naval warfare being an ex sailor myself. Have you ever thought about doing a campaign which includes supply. Great film to show this is the cruel sea. Wonderful film. I'd be very impressed if someone copied that as a campaign. Keep up the good work.

  7. Herbert flamethrower the 3rd8 February 2015 at 11:51

    Hello secret wargamer, where do I get those rules from and can I play them on my old computer? They seem to be pretty exciting and look like you have loads of fun. Have you ever dressed up.

  8. Great write up, stopped at an exciting point in the game. I will be watching with interest to see who starts to struggle with fatigue first. My money's on the boys in skirts. Great pictures, keep it up. It would be good to see some 28mm action on the table. Now that would be exciting.

  9. Love the write up buddy, good to see you've moved on from Hawaiian shirts to tartan skirts

  10. Wow those kilts are so authentic. Which clans do they belong to? Keep up the great work.

  11. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

  12. Hi buddy, me again. Just thought, have you ever thought to use warrior miniatures as they are so life like. Think about it and think about how much of a difference it would make to the look on the table.

  13. Maximus Decimus Meridius9 February 2015 at 15:56

    Wow great looking game reminds me of a similar game I played against the Germanic tribes. Good times. Unleash the dogs of war.

  14. Cool game. Wish I could be there for the conclusion. I like your 28mm scale figures that you've used.

  15. Great report SW. Who is the foxy chick called Betty? Any chance of hooking me up with her please.

  16. SW - It seems that you have a lot of followers for this post? - I hope none of them are an infelicity?


Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Not tonight Josephine - 28mm Napoleonic skirmish game

My Secret Wargaming friend has been busy, he has painted some figures, scratch built some buildings, and asked for others for his birthday. He has started his Napoleonic armies, something he promised he would never do, because he didn't know where it would end...................... A French sentry guards the prize - a command wagon full of secrets

For a while, my secret wargaming friend has been patiently working on this project, and it has been well worth the wait. Tonight he put on a great skirmish game. I was the British commander (represented on tabletop by a suitably dashing command figure), SWF - the French, and he too was represented by a command figure (who's tunic was a little too tight around his belly).

I had strict orders to reconnoiter a nearby town, and bring back captured supplies if possible. I had 13 men for the task, and had to cross a river to get into the town.

The British approach was from the bottom left of the picture then on toward the bridge

There was anot…

Red v Blue - Modern Spearhead rules and micro armour

A brief account of a command post exercise........ Me and a secret wargaming friend ran another walkthrough of these rules. This time we added helicopters, aircraft and artillery.The reader must bear in mind that we are just starting out in this scale, and with the rules. I have no 6mm trees or terrain, therefore, the pics will not be pretty.....Some of the models are also in a state of disrepair - I picked up a hodgepodge of second hand stuff some years ago, and they require basing and some need a little tidying up. This was a field training exercise, designed to put Brigade staff (me and my mate) through their paces and familiarise them with the concept of modern warfare. I took command of the red forces, which were simulating Russian units, my secret wargaming friend took charge of blue, and had a British battlegroup to command.In summary, red force was made up of three T72 tank battalions, a Motor Rifle battalion in BMP's, supported by a 122mm self propelled artillery battery, a…

Dreadnoughts Rising -World War One naval wargame (dry run)

In preparation for the final game in our World War One trilogy, I took a set of computer moderated rules called DREADNOUGHT RISING for a spin. Click here for a reviewNow I started naval wargaming in the early 1990's after buying a starter set from Skytrex. I got four World War 1 Battlecruisers and a set of basic rules, and eventually me and two friends started wargaming, we got some 15mm WW1 figures and ran a couple of mini campaigns. The only problem was the rules were hideous, and we never got to finish a game.

I recall moving my naval ships in millimetres and rolling dice a bazillion times to score and record a hit.

We loved it, but were held back by the rules. Dreadnoughts Rising solves it do her sister rules for WW2 - Battleships Zenith.

Now all I need are some computer moderated rules for my 1:3000th modern ships.....I digress, here is a summary of the test battle. The one we will play for the deciding game of the trilogy will be a little larger.I had two Battles…